Spend Like an Average American and Retire 10-13 Years Early

As I define it, frugality is the habit of living well below your means by spending less. When practiced over the long haul, the most important benefit frugality delivers is personal freedom: freedom from debt, freedom from want, and, most importantly, freedom from having to work for a living.

If you’re fortunate enough to earn an above average income—or if you and your spouse jointly earn such an income—this kind of freedom is well within reach.

All you have to do is make a single commitment: instead of spending like a typical household within your income bracket, you need to spend like an average middle-class American household (or if you want, a bit less than that). Because you spend at or about the national average, you don’t force yourself and those who live with you into a life of abject depravation. You simply spend money at about the national norm.

If you can make this single commitment and stick to it, then you likely can retire ten to thirteen years earlier than typical spenders within your income bracket. That’s more than a decade of personal freedom that you can enjoy before you’re so calcified that you have to spend your time in golf carts or, worse yet, rocking chairs. You’re still in good enough shape to bike, hike, and kayak even.

In today’s post, I’ll present simple linear models to show the massive difference that spending less can make in your life. The data for these models comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistic’s 2012 Consumer Expenditure Survey (CES). Specifically, the models rely upon CES Table 2301, which reports the spending habits of those who make $70,000 or more per year before taxes. Table 2301 splits this data into five separate income brackets. (To view Table 2301 in its entirety, click here.)

I use the CES data to build several linear models of savings growth, one for each of the five upper income brackets. These simple models contain two assumptions. First, they assume that savings grow at five percent each year. Second, they assume that the point of retirement is reached when a four percent withdrawal from accumulated savings is sufficient to fund annual spending. For example, if annual household expenses total $40,000, the models assume the income earner(s) can choose to retire when accumulated savings reach $1,000,000 (because four percent of $1 million is $40,000). This four percent rule is a well-recognized threshold for retirement, but a more demanding threshold could be substituted in its place as long as it were applied consistently to all the scenarios that the models summarize.

Table No. 1 below summarizes the CES data and reports the nest egg retirement threshold for each income bracket.

Table No. 1: 2012 CES Data & Retirement Threshold

Income Mean Average Income After Mean Average Nest Egg Needed
Bracket Taxes, Soc. Sec. & Pensions Spending to Retire
$70,000-$79,999 $66,653 $53,875 $1,346,875
$80,000-$99,999 $78,661 $59,766 $1,494,150
$100,000-$119,999 $96,023 $68,275 $1,706,875
$120,000-$149,999 $115,114 $77,201 $1,930,025
$150,000 & up $212,333 $107,860 $2,696,500
US Mean Average $58,132 $46,204 $1,155,100

Let’s begin with an example that uses the CES reported figures for the $100,000-$119,999 income bracket, which might reflect a household of two persons who each earn an average annual income of just over $50,000.

If the household spends like a typical one within its income bracket, which I call a “mainstream” household, annual expenses would run $68,275 and annual savings would total $27,748 ($96,023 – $68,275 = $27,748). If, however, the household spends at the national average for all households, which I refer to as a “frugal” household, annual expenses would run $46,204 and annual savings would total $49,819 ($96,023 – $46,204 = $49,819).

As Table No. 1 reports, the frugal household spends less so it needs to accumulate only $1,155,100 to fund retirement. The mainstream household spends more and thus needs to accumulate $1,706,875. Assuming earnings of five percent per year, the frugal household would take only sixteen (16) years to reach the retirement threshold while the mainstream household would take twenty-nine (29) years. The table below compares the frugal and mainstream scenarios side-by-side.

Table No. 2: Frugal & Mainstream Scenarios $100,000-$119,000 Income Bracket

Frugal Scenario Mainstream Scenario
Year Accumulated Savings Earned Interest Accumulated Savings Earned Interest
1 $49,819 $2,491 $27,748 $1,387
2 $102,129 $5,106 $56,883 $2,844
3 $157,054 $7,853 $87,476 $4,374
4 $214,726 $10,736 $119,597 $5,980
5 $275,281 $13,764 $153,325 $7,666
6 $338,864 $16,943 $188,739 $9,437
7 $405,627 $20,281 $225,924 $11,296
8 $475,727 $23,786 $264,969 $13,248
9 $549,332 $27,467 $305,965 $15,298
10 $626,618 $31,331 $349,011 $17,451
11 $707,768 $35,388 $394,210 $19,710
12 $792,975 $39,649 $441,668 $22,083
13 $882,443 $44,122 $491,500 $24,575
14 $976,384 $48,819 $543,823 $27,191
15 $1,075,022 $53,751 $598,762 $29,938
16 $1,178,593 $58,930 $656,448 $32,822
17 $1,287,341 $64,367 $717,018 $35,851
18 $1,401,527 $70,076 $780,617 $39,031
19 $1,521,423 $76,071 $847,396 $42,370
20 $1,647,313 $82,366 $917,514 $45,876
21 $1,779,497 $88,975 $991,138 $49,557
22 $1,918,291 $95,915 $1,068,443 $53,422
23 $2,064,025 $103,201 $1,149,613 $57,481
24 $2,217,045 $110,852 $1,234,841 $61,742
25 $2,377,716 $118,886 $1,324,332 $66,217
26 $2,546,421 $127,321 $1,418,296 $70,915
27 $2,723,561 $136,178 $1,516,959 $75,848
28 $2,909,558 $145,478 $1,620,555 $81,028
29 $3,104,855 $155,243 $1,729,331 $86,467

As Table No. 2 proves, a lifestyle of frugality turbocharges your drive towards retirement. Because you spend less each year, your nest egg grows faster than the nest egg of a mainstream household. And because you continue to spend less once your retirement years arrive, you can retire comfortably on smaller savings.

When I apply this same Table No. 2 model to the other CES upper income brackets, the results show that living like an average US household consistently provides a decade or more of additional retirement regardless of the income bracket involved. The years of freedom gained in each model is reported in Table No. 3 below. Click the highlighted dollar amounts of any income bracket for a link to the supporting data.

Table No. 3: Years Required to Reach Retirement Threshold

Income Frugal Mainstream Years of
Bracket Scenario Scenario Freedom Gained
$70,000-$79,999 28 38 10
$80,000-$99,999 21 32 11
$100,000-$119,999 16 29 13
$120,000-$149,999 13 26 13
$150,000 & up 7 17 10

If you’re trying to decide whether to adopt a more frugal lifestyle, these models can help you work through some fundamental questions that most people never bother to ask.

1. Would you rather: (a) spend in line with those who make incomes similar to you; or (b) spend like an average American household and retire a decade or more sooner than others in your income bracket?

2. Is it easier to spend like an average American household if you were brought up in one? Is it easier to spend like an average American household if that’s the way you’ve been spending money in the past?

3. If you wanted to drop your spending down to the national average of $46,204, how would you go about doing it? Would other members of your family be willing to spend less?

4. In order to retire a decade or more early, would you be willing to live in a 1600 square foot home as opposed to one which was twice as large? Would you be willing to buy used cars instead of new ones and drive them until they died? Would you be willing to visit restaurants less often than four times per week (which is the national average)? Would you be willing to take fewer vacations and stay closer to home when you did?

5. Would you be willing to hire tax experts and adopt detailed strategies in order to save on federal and state income taxes?

6. Would you be willing to spend a hour of your free time per week to investigate and implement various money saving strategies and tactics?

*   *   *

So these are some of the basic questions. How you answer them is of course up to you. If you decide to instill more frugality into your life, there’s a vast community of bloggers who are engaged in the same process. For starters, you can read past posts here or check out the blog roll at the bottom of this page. If you want to check out my book about spending less on household expenses (the Kindle version sells for a frugal $0.99), you can see the opening pages for FREE by clicking here.

Get Articles Via Email

Binge on the Frugal Fringe! Enter your email address to get future posts by email.


3 Responses to Spend Like an Average American and Retire 10-13 Years Early

  1. Free To Pursue June 9, 2014 at 9:13 AM #

    Thanks for the tables. It’s nice to see where we are relative to US mean average spending. Apparently, we’re well under. Here here to positive reinforcement.

  2. debt debs August 2, 2014 at 6:53 AM #

    When I read this it is somewhat comforting because it means there are a number of frugal people out there bringing down the average from typical. On the other hand, maybe it’s the population living in poverty that is bringing down the average and that makes me sad. It’s interesting because in some ways it seems in contradiction to the other stats on Net Worth – i.e. why is there so little net worth when the average American is spending less than Typical American? But you can also look at it this way – if the average spending is brought down by people in poverty, no wonder the net worths are so low.

    Statistics was never my best subject, but I’m glad I have you, Noonan, to explain them to me. 😉
    debt debs recently posted…Monkey Butt: The Power of NowMy Profile

    • A Noonan Moose August 2, 2014 at 7:07 AM #

      You’re right: poverty does drag down the averages for aggregate spending and net worth. Thanks for stopping by DD!

Please Leave a Comment:

CommentLuv badge

DISCLAIMER. All information on this website appears on an "AS IS" basis. A Noonan Moose makes no representations to any reader as to the completeness, accuracy, or suitability of the information that appears on this website. A Noonan Moose specifically disclaims liability of any kind for any damage or loss that arises from any of the information published on this website or in the book Spend Less Now!